FREE Car Insurance Comparison

Currently insured?

Free Car Insurance Comparison

Compare Quotes from Top Companies and Save

Currently insured?

Extra Charges by Car Insurance Companies for Bad Credit

Here's what you need to know...
  • Having bad credit can seriously impact your ability to secure affordable car insurance
  • Credit scores are determined by a calculation that takes various factors into consideration
  • A credit score in the 700s is considered excellent whereas a score below 620 is considered poor

Since bad credit is viewed as high risk, car insurance companies take advantage of the statistics that say people bad credit are more prone to take chances and submit insurance claims when compared to people with good credit.

Whether this is a fair analysis or not, the only way to really avoid getting penalized for having bad credit is to work on regaining good credit.

Compare your car insurance rates by entering your zip code above in the FREE rate tool above now!

What determines a bad credit rating for car insurance rates?


Car insurance companies charge extra money for having bad credit whenever they are allowed to do so by law. Since laws vary from state to state, not all insurance companies charge a higher premium if you have bad credit.

Credit scores are determined by a calculation that takes various factors into consideration. FICO (Fair Isaac Corporation) is the industry standard for credit reporting and sets the basis for the top three credit reporting agencies to determine their individual credit scores.

In 2008, FICO changed their credit scoring system to help take a consumer’s complete credit history into consideration.

Understanding how insurance companies use credit rates is important. Some of the main changes that effect FICO’s role in your credit score include a debt collection efforts that is less than $100.

One change that may affect people differently is the diversity of your credit history. If you have a mix of loan types, such as secured (mortgage or auto) loans, unsecured (credit cards) loans, and student loans you will have a better credit score then if your credit report is made up only of one type of loan, such as credit card debt.

Free Car Insurance Comparison

Compare Quotes From Top Companies and Save

Currently insured?

The Cons of the FICO Scoring System

Several negative impacts also come with the new FICO scoring system. For example, the less available credit you have, the lower your score will be. This means that if your debt is close to your credit limit, it will have a negative impact on your credit report.

In addition, while you may be tempted to close your accounts to help reduce your debt and maintain a cleaner credit report, closing your accounts is actually detrimental to your credit score.

While FICO set the new credit score range based on their change in calculations, you may still find out you have a different credit score from each of the three top credit reporting agencies.

That is because while the agencies use the FICO standard, each credit bureau has its own methodology for reviewing your credit history and calculating your credit score.

Although your credit score may be slightly higher or slightly lower from one agency to the next, it will most likely fall within the same category range.

A credit score in the high 700s is the best score you can obtain. The absolute highest your score can be is 850. A credit score that is in the mid to high 700s is considered to be excellent and the low 700s are very good.

A good score or average score falls between 680 and 699 and anything from 620 to 679 is acceptable, which means you will probably not be denied credit but you won’t get the most favorable rates.

If your credit score is below 620 but above 580, you are in a credit risk category. This score is considered low and borders on a bad credit score of 500 to 579.

The lowest range your credit score can be is 300 and anything that falls from 300 to 500 represents a very serious credit problem that requires professional help.

States that Allow the Use of Credit Rating to Determine Car Insurance Rates

united-states-map-eps-78275004-1600x1600Just as laws vary from state to state, laws change within the states. To find out if your state allows your car insurance company to use your credit report to determine your car insurance rate, call your state insurance commissioner. Most car insurance companies will ask for your social security number but you may not have to disclose it.

Having a social security number may make it easier to request a motor vehicle report and a CLUE report, but they are not required for those documents. A motor vehicle report will disclose any tickets, violations, or acts of suspension on your driver’s license.

A CLUE (Comprehensive Loss Underwriting Exchange) report will reveal your insurance claims history. While these can be used to determine your rate regardless of the state you live in, they are not associated with your credit report.

Before you agree to a credit report, confirm if your state allows the use of it or not. If your state doesn’t allow the use of your credit report, then you should consider finding a different insurance company that will not use your credit score, especially if your credit score is low.

How You Can Lower Your Car Insurance Rate with Bad Credit

States that allow car insurance companies to charge more money for having bad credit don’t leave you with many options. Most car insurance companies offer competitive rating and use similar methods to reduce the rates you are quoted.

The first option is to shop around for lower rates from different car insurance carriers since competitive pricing usually works in the consumer’s favor. The next option is to take advantage of every discount and credit you can manage.

Try to get multi-car discounts, multi-policy discounts, good driving discounts, car security credit, car safety credit, good student driving credit, and accident-free credit.

In order to raise your credit score, work on reducing your debt to limit ratio. Stop using your credit cards if they are out of control and start paying down your debt.

Make at least the minimum payments on every card and then choose the card with the closest dept to limit ratio and pay extra on that card each month.

Keep the credit card locked away and only use it occasionally to make a small purchase that you pay off in full right away. This will help keep your available limits high, your debts low, and show financial responsibility which will ultimately increase your credit score and lower your car insurance rate.

As mentioned above, once you have a bad credit score it is likely that your car insurance rates will increase. Even if you are a responsible driver and you never have insurance claims, statistics show that people with lower credit scores are considered.

Does a good driving record help lower my car insurance rates if I have bad credit?


A solid history of driving safely can help your car insurance rates become and stay low even if you have bad credit. Most car insurance companies will look very favorably on a safe driving record, and it may even offset any increase in cost from a poor credit rating.

If you have avoided accidents and have not received any moving violations over the previous three years, you are considered a good driver.

Many car insurance companies offer a good driver discount that can save you as much as 10 percent off your car insurance premium. The average increase in car insurance rates for poor credit is between 5 percent and 10 percent.

If I have bad credit, will I have many choices with car insurance companies?

If you have a low credit score or poor credit, you will be limited as far as how many different car insurance companies will offer you coverage for your vehicles. Some car insurance companies will not offer insurance coverage to you if you have poor credit.

However, some car insurance companies that specialize in offering car insurance coverage for people that have poor credit. The rates that you pay with these car insurance companies are usually substantially higher than traditional companies.

In addition, many of these companies will require a higher down payment to secure coverage. However, these companies do not look at your credit score when extending insurance coverage.

You can learn about the different car insurance companies and their financial strength by visiting A.M. Best’s website.

Enter your zip code below and get FREE car insurance rates now!

Copyright © 2018 · All Rights Reserved · Car Insurance Comparison · Terms & Conditions · About Us · Privacy Policy · Contact Us · Site Map · Resources

Currently insured?